Insomnia or Sleep Apnea? How to Tell the Difference and Treat Both

Insomnia and sleep apnea share symptoms, so it’s easy to mix them up. However, understanding the nuances can be the key to healthier sleep. Insomnia is characterized by difficulty falling or staying asleep, whereas sleep apnea interrupts breathing during sleep. Interestingly, many people experience both, leading to a condition known as COMISA.

How Do the Symptoms Compare?

FeatureMore Typical of InsomniaMore Typical of Sleep Apnea
Main problemTrouble falling or staying asleepBreathing interruptions during sleep
NightLying awake, racing thoughts, clock watchingSnoring, gasping, choking, or pauses
Morning Unrefreshed, wired but tiredHeadache, dry mouth, unrefreshed
Daytime Fatigue, poor focus, irritabilityStrong sleepiness, dozing off, poor focus
Other cluesWorry about sleep, bedtime anxietyHigh blood pressure, large neck size

A helpful distinction: While insomnia often leaves you feeling tired but unable to nap, sleep apnea causes a sleepiness that makes staying awake challenging.

How Common Is It to Have Both?

Quite common, in fact. In sleep clinics, about 30-50% of those with sleep apnea report insomnia symptoms, while 30-40% of chronic insomniacs test positive for sleep apnea. Population studies vary, but generally support significant overlap.

Why Does It Matter If You Have Both?

COMISA often results in worse sleep and lower quality of life than either condition alone. It complicates treatment adherence, especially with CPAP devices, and leaves untreated symptoms lingering.

What Is the Right Order of Care?

Start with a medical evaluation if you exhibit apnea symptoms. The right tools and approaches can vary, and a health professional can determine whether a home sleep test or lab study is more appropriate. Combined approaches often yield the best results:

CBT-I Works in COMISA: Randomized trials show that CBT-I improves insomnia severity and CPAP compliance. CBT-I plus CPAP is Effective: Together, these treatments improve both use and symptoms better than CPAP alone.

Consider that certain sedatives might worsen apnea symptoms, so always disclose your full condition to healthcare providers before starting sleep medication.

Want a Free Starting Point?

Join the free sleep course and community: Join the Sleep Nirvana Club

When to Seek Professional Help

  • You snore loudly or experience gasping or choking during sleep.

  • Daytime sleepiness or dozing off easily.

  • Waking with headaches or dry mouth.

  • Existing treatments for insomnia have not worked.

  • You have high blood pressure or related conditions alongside poor sleep.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if I have insomnia or sleep apnea?

Consult a doctor, as symptoms overlap. Snoring, gasping, and morning headaches lean towards apnea, whereas insomnia involves struggling to sleep despite opportunities.

Can you have both insomnia and sleep apnea?

Yes, approximately 30-50% of sleep clinic patients with apnea report insomnia and vice versa.

Which should I treat first, insomnia or sleep apnea?

Start with a medical evaluation if symptoms suggest apnea. Treating both via CBT-I and CPAP is generally most effective.

Does CPAP cure insomnia?

While it may reduce symptoms, many still require insomnia-specific treatment.

Can sleeping pills make sleep apnea worse?

Yes, some sedatives affect breathing, so always consult your healthcare provider beforehand.